Boron

    group 13 · period 2 · p-block · metalloid

    fullBoron has a WHO guideline of 2.4 mg/L and an EU parametric value of 1.5 mg/L, sits in seawater at over 4 mg/L so that every desalination plant must design for it, passes conventional treatment and slips through reverse osmosis at neutral pH as uncharged boric acid, and is the classic irrigation toxicant above 0.7 mg/L; the treatment story is one acid base equilibrium at pH 9.2.

    Typical wastewaters

    • seawater desalination (reverse osmosis brine and permeate) uncharged boric acid B(OH)₃ at seawater pH 8.1, 4.4 mg/L in the feed, concentrated in the reject and passing a single membrane pass only in part WHO: the guideline will be difficult to achieve in some desalinated supplies; the EU allows 2.4 mg/L where desalinated water predominates
    • municipal sewage and detergent, glass, soap and flame retardant manufacture borate from perborate detergents and manufacturing discharges, falling as perborate use declines
    • textile finishing boric acid, diboron trioxide and sodium borates as total boron; 100 µg/L reporting limit (ZDHC Table 1J), borate zinc salt also reported as boron
    • borax and boric acid production borate in residual brine and depleted liquor returned to the source water body; no other process wastewater discharge

    1 · Identity

    Symbol, number
    B, 5
    Oxidation states in water
    +3 only, as boric acid B(OH)₃ (an uncharged, monomeric weak Lewis acid) below about pH 9 and as the borate anion B(OH)₄⁻ above it; polyborates appear only at concentrations far above natural water. No redox chemistry in water.
    Note
    The element entry carries the borate minerals, the Turkish and Californian deposits and the glass, detergent and flame retardant uses. This chapter is boron as a dissolved weak acid.

    2 · Occurrence in water

    Natural sources
    Leaching from rocks and soils containing borates and borosilicates, the primary route into groundwater (WHO); orthoboric acid in volcanic spring waters (element entry); seawater, where boron is a major minor constituent at about 4.4 mg/L; concentrations vary widely with the surrounding geology (WHO).
    Anthropogenic sources
    Wastewater discharges of borate from detergents, glass, soap and flame retardant manufacture, although perborate use in detergents has fallen and boron in wastewater discharges continues to fall (WHO); desalinated water, where boron rejection is incomplete (EU DWD note); irrigation with borate rich water; borax and boric acid plants, which in the US may return only residual brine to the source water body.
    matrixtypical rangenote
    drinking water, worldbelow 0.5 mg/Lregion-dependentjudged to be below 0.5 mg/L for most of the world; varies widely with geology and wastewater discharges
    groundwater, US public water systemsmedian 0.0514 mg/L
    US surveys quoted in the 2008 health advisory
    81.9 percent of groundwater systems had detections at or above 0.005 mg/L; 4.3 percent of surveyed systems above 0.7 mg/L (half the 1.4 mg/L health reference level); 7 of 228 samples in a second survey above 1.4 mg/L
    surface water, US public water systemsmedian 0.029 mg/LUS surveysame survey
    seawater4.44 mg/Lsingle figureoceanic abundance figure, Jefferson Lab via PubChem, quoted in the element entry; the feed concentration every seawater reverse osmosis plant designs against
    high borate regions2.05 to 29 mg/Lregion-dependent; study areasdrinking water in a high borate region against 0.03 to 0.4 mg/L in a low borate region; well water 1.2 to 25.1 mg/L in a boron area (epidemiological study areas quoted by EPA)
    municipal and industrial wastewaternot read WHO says discharges raise surface water borate but gives no concentration; no effluent survey read

    3 · Speciation

    Boric acid is a weak acid with pKa about 9.2 at 25 C, and it dissociates not by losing a proton but by taking up a hydroxide to form the tetrahedral borate ion. Below pH 8 nearly all boron is the uncharged, small B(OH)₃ molecule; at pH 9.2 half is B(OH)₄⁻; above pH 10.5 nearly all is borate. Ionic strength and temperature shift the pKa, seawater to about 8.6 (Stumm and Morgan). Everything in boron treatment follows: the uncharged acid is not rejected well by membranes, not adsorbed by conventional media and not precipitated; the anion is.

    conditiondominant speciesnote
    fresh water, pH below 8B(OH)₃uncharged; passes reverse osmosis in part and conventional treatment entirely
    pH 8.5 to 10B(OH)₃ and B(OH)₄⁻ togetherseawater at pH 8.1 has boron mostly as boric acid
    pH above 10.5B(OH)₄⁻the condition for high rejection in a second reverse osmosis pass and for anion exchange
    borate brines and evaporitespolyborates such as B₄O₇²⁻, precipitating as borax and colemanitenot met in treatment; the element entry has the minerals
    Solubility
    Boric acid and the alkali borates are soluble; calcium and magnesium borates are sparingly soluble but do not control boron at treatment concentrations. No solubility is quoted because none was read.
    Hydrolysis
    Boric acid does not hydrolyse further; the tetraborate of borax hydrolyses in dilute solution to boric acid and borate.
    Complexation
    Boric acid complexes with polyols (cis diols), which is the chemistry of boron selective resins carrying N-methyl-D-glucamine groups and of the classical mannitol titration; it also esterifies with the diol groups of natural organic matter (general chemistry, not quantified in the sources read).
    Precipitates
    None of significance in natural or treated water; co-precipitation with Mg(OH)₂ in lime softening at high pH is reported in the literature but was not read this session.
    B(OH)X3+HX2OB(OH)X4X+HX+\ce{B(OH)3 + H2O <=> B(OH)4^- + H+}
    pKa about 9.2 at 25 C and zero ionic strength, lower in seawater; boric acid acts as a Lewis acid, accepting hydroxide rather than donating a proton
    B(OH)X3+OHXB(OH)X4X\ce{B(OH)3 + OH- -> B(OH)4^-}
    caustic dosing before a second reverse osmosis pass or an anion exchanger; converts the poorly rejected acid to the well rejected anion
    NaX2BX4OX7+7HX2O2B(OH)X3+2B(OH)X4X+2NaX+\ce{Na2B4O7 + 7 H2O -> 2 B(OH)3 + 2 B(OH)4^- + 2 Na^+}
    dissolution of borax (sodium tetraborate) in dilute water; the reason a borax solution sits near pH 9.2 and is a buffer standard
    B(OH)X4X+HX+B(OH)X3+HX2O\ce{B(OH)4^- + H+ -> B(OH)3 + H2O}
    the reverse of the pKa 9.2 dissociation: acidification, or the acid elution step of a boron selective resin, returns borate to the uncharged acid; the reason boron in any water at neutral pH, and in every acidified sample bottle, is B(OH)3

    4 · Role in treatment

    as a problem
    boron in desalinated water
    seawater carries 4.4 mg/L boron mostly as uncharged boric acid at pH 8.1, which a single reverse osmosis pass rejects only in part
    the EU allows 2.4 mg/L instead of 1.5 mg/L where desalinated water is the predominant source; WHO notes the guideline will be difficult to achieve in some desalinated supplies and in areas of high natural boron
    conventional treatment does not remove boron
    no precipitate, no adsorption on floc, no biological uptake of consequence
    WHO: coagulation, sedimentation and filtration do not significantly remove boron
    irrigation toxicity
    boron accumulates in leaves of sensitive crops from irrigation water
    FAO 29: no restriction below 0.7 mg/L, slight to moderate 0.7 to 3.0, severe above 3.0 mg/L; recycled water for agriculture must meet the crop, not the drinking water guideline
    reverse osmosis brine and ion exchange regenerant
    boron removed from product water is concentrated in the reject or in the regenerant
    WHO: ion exchange and reverse osmosis are likely to be prohibitively expensive; blending with low boron supplies may be the only economical method
    textile effluent
    boric acid and borates from finishing chemistry
    ZDHC reporting limit 100 µg/L as total boron for boric acid, boron oxide and sodium borates in textile wastewater, Table 1J
    as a reagent
    none as a treatment reagent
    boron is a contaminant, not a reagent; borax is a pH buffer standard in the laboratory

    5 · Removal and control

    reverse osmosis, single pass
    membrane rejection of B(OH)₃ is far lower than of salts because the molecule is small and uncharged; rejection rises with pH as borate forms
    seawater at pH 8.1 in the first pass; WHO lists reverse osmosis among the special methods that may enable substantial reduction; no rejection percentage was read this session
    Efficiency
    substantial but incomplete (WHO); not quantified in the sources read
    Interferences
    low feed pH, high temperature and high recovery all lower boron rejection (general membrane practice, not from a source read)
    reverse osmosis, second pass at high pH
    caustic soda raises the first pass permeate to pH 10 to 11, converting boric acid to borate, which the second pass rejects like a salt
    B(OH)X3+OHXB(OH)X4X\ce{B(OH)3 + OH- -> B(OH)4^-}
    the permeate has little hardness so scaling at high pH is limited; the design of every large seawater plant that must meet 1.5 mg/L or less (general practice built on the pKa, not from a source read)
    Efficiency
    to below 1 mg/L in practice; no figure read
    Interferences
    carbonate scaling if hardness remains
    boron selective ion exchange
    resin with N-methyl-D-glucamine groups complexes boric acid through its diol; regenerated with acid then caustic
    polishing of reverse osmosis permeate or groundwater; WHO lists ion exchange among the special methods; the resin chemistry is general knowledge, not from a source read
    Efficiency
    not quantified
    blending
    dilution with a low boron source
    WHO: may be the only economical method where concentrations are high
    Efficiency
    arithmetic
    conventional treatment
    none
    coagulation, sedimentation and filtration do not significantly remove boron (WHO); the US BAT table of 40 CFR 141.62 has no boron row because boron is unregulated
    Efficiency
    nil

    6 · Analytics

    methodstandarddetection limitnote
    ICP-MSEPA 200.8; ISO 17294-20.15 µg/L (WHO)memory effects from boron in the sample introduction system; use a rinse with ammonia or mannitol (general practice)
    ICP-OESEPA 200.7; Standard Methods 3120 B; ISO 118856 to 10 µg/L (WHO, ICP-AES)the ZDHC method for total boron
    colorimetry (curcumin, carmine, azomethine-H)Standard Methods 4500-B B and C; ISO 9390 (azomethine-H)not readfield and small laboratory methods
    Sampling pitfalls
    Never use borosilicate glass for boron samples or standards; boron leaches from the glass. Use polyethylene bottles. No acidification is needed for dissolved boron, and filtration is unnecessary because boron is not particulate; acidified metal samples in glass bottles give false boron. Total boron and boric acid are the same number at any pH the laboratory sees.

    7 · Regulatory limits

    Limits change, and many are set locally. Treat these as the published values to start from, not as your compliance target: check the standard in force at your site and the numbers written into your own permit.

    drinking water
    bodylimitnote
    WHO GDWQ 4th ed. with addenda (2022)2.4 mg/LTDI 0.17 mg/kg body weight from a BMDL₀₅ of 10.3 mg/kg per day for decreased fetal body weight in rats and an uncertainty factor of 60; 40 percent allocation to water because other intake is low; 60 kg, 2 L/day; assessment 2009; where the value is difficult to achieve in desalinated or naturally high supplies, authorities should consider a value above 2.4 mg/L by assessing other exposure
    EU DWD 2020/21841.5 mg/LAnnex I Part B; a parametric value of 2.4 mg/L applies when desalinated water is the predominant source of the supply system or in regions where geological conditions could lead to high boron in groundwater
    US EPAnot regulated no MCL; 2008 health advisory: one-day and ten-day 3.0 mg/L (child), longer-term 2.0 mg/L (child) and 5 mg/L (adult), lifetime 5 mg/L from a DWEL of 7.0 mg/L and RfD 0.2 mg/kg per day; CCL health reference level 1.4 mg/L
    discharge
    bodylimitnote
    EU CWW BREF BAT-AEL (Decision 2016/902)not set boron is not among the BAT 12 parameters
    US EPA 40 CFR 415.272, borax production (BPT)no limit no discharge of process wastewater pollutants to navigable waters except return of residual brine and depleted liquor to the source water body; boron itself is not a limited parameter
    Abu Dhabi ADS 23/2017, discharge to the marine environment (EAD)1.0 mg/L
    region-dependent; marine discharge only; below ambient seawater boron
    Table 1 maximum allowable concentration at the point of discharge; below the seawater concentration, which the specification exempts by excluding desalination brine
    Abu Dhabi DoE Trade Effluent Control Regulations 2022, discharge to sewer5 mg/L
    region-dependent; sewer discharge
    Table A₄
    industry thresholds
    sectorbodylimitnote
    textileZDHC Wastewater Guidelines v₂.1 (2022), Table 1J boric acid, diboron trioxide, disodium octaborate, disodium tetraborate100 µg/Lreporting limit for textile wastewater, determined as total boron by ICP; the limit refers to elemental boron, not the salt; borate zinc salt 100 µg/L each as boron and zinc (Table 1N)
    irrigationFAO Irrigation and Drainage Paper 29 (1985), Table 1below 0.7 no restriction; 0.7 to 3.0 slight to moderate; above 3.0 severe mg/Lspecific ion toxicity to sensitive crops; the usual normal range in irrigation water is 0 to 2 mg/L

    8 · Health and environmental effects

    Toxicity
    Boron is essential for plant cell walls and probably not for humans; daily intake about 2 mg from food (element entry). In animals the male reproductive tract is the consistent target (testicular lesions in rats, mice and dogs) and developmental toxicity is demonstrated in rats, mice and rabbits; boric acid and borax are not genotoxic and caused no tumours in long term studies (WHO). EPA's RfD of 0.2 mg/kg per day rests on the BMDL for decreased fetal body weight with a data derived adjustment factor of 66.
    Bioaccumulation
    Not addressed in the sources read; boron accumulates in the leaves of irrigated crops, which is the basis of the FAO limits.
    Ecotoxicity
    US EPA national recommended criteria list boron with a narrative statement in the 1986 Gold Book and no numeric criterion; the numeric guidance in use is the FAO irrigation threshold.

    Flags

    • The pKa of boric acid and the shift in seawater are cited to Stumm and Morgan from memory of the text, not re-read this session.
    • Two-pass reverse osmosis at high pH and the glucamine resin are general practice; WHO names ion exchange and reverse osmosis without describing them, and no rejection percentages were read.
    • US occurrence medians come from surveys quoted in the 2008 EPA health advisory, not from a current dataset.
    • The EPA health advisory values are transcribed from the 2008 document sections 5.1 to 5.4; the child longer-term value of 2.0 mg/L is taken from the summary read, the derivation itself was not checked line by line.
    • Abu Dhabi values cover two media (marine outfall 1.0 mg/L, sewer 5 mg/L); other GCC states not read.

    Gaps

    • No reverse osmosis boron rejection figures, resin capacities or full scale performance data were read.
    • No municipal or industrial effluent boron concentrations were read; the ZDHC reporting limit stands in for textile.
    • The WHO 2009 boron background document was not reachable at the guessed URL and was not read.
    • No solubility or polyborate constants are quoted.
    • Other GCC discharge standards were not read; Gulf desalination permits treat boron case by case and were not sourced.
    • The loading step of a boron selective resin is a diol chelation with the N-methylglucamine group; no source read prints a stoichiometry for it, so only the acid elution step is written as an equation.

    Sources

    WHO Guidelines for Drinking-water Quality, 4th ed. incorporating the first and second addenda (2022), chapter 12 chemical fact sheet, Boron (pp. 350 to 351)
    US EPA, Drinking Water Health Advisory for Boron, EPA 822-R-08-013 (May 2008), sections 2 (occurrence) and 5 (health advisories)
    Directive (EU) 2020/2184 on the quality of water intended for human consumption (recast), Annex I Parts B and C
    Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2016/902 establishing BAT conclusions for common waste water and waste gas treatment/management systems in the chemical sector (CWW), BAT 12 Tables 1 and 2 with footnotes
    40 CFR 415.272, Borax production subcategory, BPT effluent limitations
    Abu Dhabi Specification ADS 23/2017, Environmental Specifications for Land-Based Liquid Discharges to the Marine Environment (Environment Agency Abu Dhabi), Table 1
    Abu Dhabi Department of Energy, Trade Effluent Control Regulations 2022 (DoE/PD/R01/005, effective 1 January 2022), Schedule A Tables A1, A2 and A4
    ZDHC Wastewater Guidelines Version 2.1 (November 2022), Tables 1J (flame retardants, boron compounds) and 1N
    Ayers, R. S. and Westcot, D. W., Water Quality for Agriculture, FAO Irrigation and Drainage Paper 29 Rev. 1 (1985), chapter 1, Table 1 and Table 2
    US EPA, National Recommended Water Quality Criteria, Aquatic Life Criteria Table
    Stumm, W. and Morgan, J. J., Aquatic Chemistry, 3rd ed. (Wiley, 1996), chapter 3 (acids and bases, boric acid) and chapter 4 (seawater acid base constants)
    Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater (online edition), 4500-B Boron, 3120 B
    The Element Book, entries for boron (seawater abundance, borate minerals, detergents and glass) (data/elements/B.json, data/reference/text/B.json)

    Conventions

    Valence electrons are counted by the usual convention: the outer shell for s- and p-block elements, ns and (n-1)d for the d-block, ns, (n-1)d and (n-2)f for the f-block. Lanthanides and actinides are placed in the f-block with no group number. Electrical conductivity is the reciprocal of the printed resistivity. Ionic radii are Shannon effective radii, six-coordinate unless noted. Where a field reads “not in sources” the value was not found; it is a gap, not a zero. Regulatory limits are the published values and change often, so check the standard in force at your site and the numbers written into your own permit before you design to them.

    Data

    Element records, isotopes, radii and the descriptive text come from PubChem (NCBI), the Los Alamos National Laboratory periodic table, IUPAC CIAAW and the IAEA Atomic Mass Data Center. Appearance, thermal conductivity, electrical resistivity, crystal structure, discovery and the origin of each name come from Wikipedia and Periodic-Table-JSON, used under CC BY-SA 4.0. Hazard classifications come from the ECHA C&L inventory via PubChem. Ionic radii follow R. D. Shannon (1976). The water chapters cite their own sources at the foot of each entry, and are written to the level of Snoeyink and Jenkins, Stumm and Morgan, MWH's Water Treatment and Metcalf and Eddy.