Suspended solids and turbidity removal from beet washwater by electrocoagulation and settling
A farm in Quebec washes red beets grown on mineral loam, and the washwater normally flows to a non-aerated lagoon with a 14 h retention time before discharge to a nearby stream. Washwater was collected straight from the washing machine and treated in a 0.5 L laboratory cell to test electrocoagulation as a way to clarify it.
Treatment line
- 01Electrocoagulation cellBatch cell with two flat aluminium electrodes, 110 cm² each and 1 cm apart, run for 8.8 min at the conditions optimised on potato washwater.
- 02Settling60 min of settling, after which the clear liquid was drawn off and analysed.
What the source found
Electrocoagulation and settling removed 88% of turbidity, 82% of suspended solids, 75% of COD and above 99% of total phosphorus and iron. Suspended solids stayed well above the provincial discharge limit, and a red tint from the beet pigment remained in the treated water. This was the most expensive of the four washwaters tested to treat.
Raw washwater and the settled liquid after electrocoagulation at the optimised settings were analysed and reported as means with standard deviations.
Water in, water out
| Parameter | Symbol | Unit | Inlet | Outlet | Removal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| pH | 7.5 | 8.4 | |||
| Turbidity | NTU | 2,467 | 285 | 88% | |
| Total suspended solids | TSS | mg/L | 1,957 | 357 | 82% |
| COD | COD | mg/L | 479 | 118 | 75% |
| True colour | UCV | 283 | 60 | ||
| Total phosphorus | TP | mg/L | 4.2 | 0.02 | 99.5% |
| Aluminium (Al3+) | Al3+ | mg/L | 23 | 0.4 | 98% |
| Iron (Fe3+) | Fe3+ | mg/L | 37 | 0.04 | 99.9% |
| Thiamethoxam | µg/L | < 0.002 | < 0.002 | ||
| Clothianidin | µg/L | < 0.002 | < 0.002 |
Inlet: raw red beet washwater taken at the exit of the washing machine. Outlet: clear upper layer after electrocoagulation and one hour of settling. Laboratory batch electrocoagulation at 0.32 A for 8.8 minutes; means with standard deviations. Values and units are as the published source prints them. Removal is worked out from the two values, or is the source's own figure where it prints no pair.