Shrinking the concentrate from municipal water reuse by high-recovery closed-circuit RO
A municipal water reclamation facility ran a pilot on its tertiary effluent to see how far reverse osmosis recovery could be pushed and so shrink the concentrate stream of a purified water replenishment program. The effluent was first passed through ultrafiltration and an equalization tank; the figures here cover the closed-circuit RO stage that followed, and all pilot outflows went back to the head of the plant.
Treatment line
- 01Closed-circuit reverse osmosis25 RO elements in one stage, about 929 m² of membrane, fed at about 15.9 m³/h; the concentrate is recirculated until a set point and then purged, with recovery raised step by step during the trial.
What the source found
At the first and lowest recovery step the RO removed 95% of dissolved solids, 93% of organic carbon, 96% of chloride, above 99% of sulfate and 80% of nitrate, with divalent ions held back better than monovalent ones. As recovery was raised further, removal of dissolved solids, alkalinity, chloride, nitrate, sodium and potassium fell, while sulfate, calcium and magnesium removal stayed steady; the ultrafiltration ahead of it removed all suspended particles.
Samples of the RO feed, permeate and concentrate taken at each recovery step from October 2020 to May 2021, each measurement at least in triplicate, with the full set of results reported for the lowest recovery step.
Water in, water out
| Parameter | Symbol | Unit | Inlet | Outlet | Removal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| pH | 6.3 | 5.5 | |||
| Temperature | °C | 20.9 | 19.6 | ||
| Electrical conductivity | EC | µs/cm | 1,018 | 58 | |
| Total dissolved solids | TDS | mg/L | 590 | 29 | 95% |
| Total suspended solids | TSS | mg/L | not detected | ||
| Total organic carbon | TOC | mg/L | 4.7 | 0.35 | 93% |
| Alkalinity as CaCO3 | Alk | mg/L | 62 | 9.4 | |
| Turbidity | NTU | not detected | not detected | ||
| UV254 transmittance | % | 80.5 | 97.7 | ||
| Free chlorine residual as Cl2 | Cl2 | mg/L | 0.43 | ||
| Total chlorine residual as Cl2 | Cl2 | mg/L | 1.3 | ||
| Chloride | Cl− | mg/L | 120 | 4.4 | 96% |
| Fluoride | F− | mg/L | 0.18 | not detected | >99.9% |
| Nitrate as nitrogen | NO3-N | mg/L | 9.3 | 1.9 | 80% |
| Total phosphorus as phosphate | TP | mg/L | 0.56 | ||
| Sulfate as the ion | SO42− | mg/L | 180 | 0.5 | 99.7% |
| Total silica as SiO2 | SiO2 | mg/L | 23 | ||
| Ammonia as nitrogen | NH3-N | mg/L | 8.9 | ||
| Total barium | Ba | mg/L | 0.036 | ||
| Total calcium | Ca | mg/L | 50.7 | 0.133 | 99.7% |
| Total magnesium | Mg | mg/L | 6.92 | not detected | >99.9% |
| Total manganese | Mn | mg/L | 0.0051 | ||
| Total sodium | Na | mg/L | 110 | 7.7 | 93% |
| Total potassium | K | mg/L | 17 | 1.2 | 93% |
| Total iron | Fe | mg/L | 0.052 | ||
| Total aluminium | Al | mg/L | not detected | ||
| Total strontium | Sr | mg/L | 0.31 | ||
| E. coli | MPN/100 mL | not detected | not detected | ||
| Total coliforms | TC | MPN/100 mL | not detected | not detected |
Inlet: feed to the closed-circuit reverse osmosis stage. Outlet: reverse osmosis permeate. Samples at the 90% recovery step, each measurement at least in triplicate. Values and units are as the published source prints them. Removal is worked out from the two values, or is the source's own figure where it prints no pair.