Aguato

    Recovering more water from scaling-prone RO concentrate by batch reverse osmosis with a bladder

    A desalting plant in Yuma, Arizona, United States, uses reverse osmosis to desalinate saline agricultural drainage water and produces a sulfate-rich concentrate. A small batch reverse osmosis prototype was run on site on that concentrate to recover more water from it without scaling and with low energy use.

    Treatment line

    1. 01Acid dosingDilute sulfuric acid was injected occasionally to limit calcium carbonate scaling.
    2. 02Batch reverse osmosis with a flexible bladderA bladder inside a standard 20 cm RO housing pressurises a shrinking volume of circulating concentrate so that no feed enters during each roughly 10-minute permeate phase, followed by a brine flush, an osmotic backwash and a refill; designed for up to 5 m³ per day and 34.5 bar.

    What the source found

    The pilot turned more than four-fifths of the concentrate it received into permeate, producing about 4.4 m³ per day and removing about 98% of dissolved solids, 98% of sulfate, 97% of chloride, 98% of silica and 94% of nitrate, but only about 60% of boron. Although the brine became supersaturated with gypsum and other scalants, performance did not decline during the week. The specific energy use of the small prototype was 3.3 kWh/m³, and a full-scale system was modelled at under 1 kWh/m³.

    One week of nearly continuous operation covering 885 batch cycles, with flows and power logged continuously and 21 permeate, 7 feed and 2 concentrate samples analysed.

    Water in, water out

    ParameterSymbolUnitInletOutletRemoval
    BariumBamg/L0.050.000799%
    BoronBmg/L1.110.4460%
    CalciumCamg/L3164.998%
    ChlorideCl−mg/L1,5434397%
    FluorideF−mg/L<10.41.8
    IronFemg/L0.0390.00880%
    MagnesiumMgmg/L1522.698%
    Nitrate nitrogenNO3-Nmg/L191.194%
    PotassiumKmg/L22.70.5498%
    Silicon dioxideSiO2mg/L190.498%
    SodiumNamg/L1,7144497%
    StrontiumSrmg/L4.490.0798%
    SulfateSO42−mg/L2,5214498%
    Total dissolved solidsTDSmg/L6,36615098%
    pH5.85.9
    PhosphatePO43−mg/Lbelow detection limitbelow detection limit

    Inlet: brine from an existing desalination plant fed to the batch reverse osmosis unit. Outlet: permeate of the batch reverse osmosis unit. Means of 7 feed samples taken weekly around and during the pilot and of 21 permeate samples from one week of operation. Values and units are as the published source prints them. Removal is worked out from the two values, or is the source's own figure where it prints no pair.

    Similar references